3d illustration of a Harmful man talking to a man in a room.

Can ABA Be Harmful

Understanding the Complexities of ABA: Positive Impact and Potential Harms

Short answer? Yes, it can potentially be, but it’s a lot more complicated than that. While the application of the science of ABA can be positively life-changing for many individuals and their families, there are a number of ABA recipients who have been harmed by this type of therapy, developing PTSD at higher rates than their non-participating peers (Kupferstein, 2018). Many autistic people have assumed an anti-ABA stance, proclaiming all ABA to be abusive by its very nature.

As a late-diagnosed autistic, pro-ABA BCBA with ADHD who never received ABA, and who has also been an ABA practitioner for 15 years, I’m in kind of an odd position. If ABA can harm autistic people, how can I argue in its favor? I’ve worked with hundreds of families and personally seen ABA be incredibly helpful and make individuals happier and safer, and I’ve also seen it do nothing or make things worse. Yet, I still champion high-quality, person-centered, responsive, compassionate, humble, trauma-informed, collaborative, ethical, consistent, flexible, and brief ABA programs. These are the kinds of programs and clinicians that serve people in need.

And ABA can, and is, absolutely be applied for the greater good and quality of life for society. Meaningful incentivization can produce wonderful effects when people are otherwise unmotivated to change. We see this every day. MycuraJOY delivers content and learning that are based in ABA strategies because we know that they work. We do it unintrusively, privately, in small chunks, and in the form of family-based intervention. The strategies themselves are not inherently abusive. It’s what people are attempting to change that is the problem. Training autistic characteristics out of autistic people is abusive. Creating a positive plan to teach new skills in small steps that ultimately benefit the learner, like effective communication, is not.

ABA is not appropriate for every person, every behavior, or every skill. Many other disciplines also provide care for neurodivergent people, but for many, the systematic, repetitive, highly structured, home-based nature of ABA is exactly what is needed.

Insurance and providers owe it to families to educate them about autism, what ABA entails, the level of commitment it takes, possible side effects, available alternative treatments, and their active role on treatment teams. Providers should be incredibly discerning in assessing and determining “goodness of fit”. We should be in touch with our clients’ other therapies and seek guidance from other disciplines.

Many ABA practitioners have taken feedback from autistic adults and changed the way they practice as a result. Science and treatments are always evolving, and ABA is a newcomer that’s growing and changing. It wasn’t that long ago that psychologists were drilling holes in people’s skulls to let illnesses out and disabled people were categorically left to rot in sanitariums. We still have a long way to go, but as a young science, we are open to feedback and wish to evolve.

Response to “Can ABA Be Harmful”

  1. Caitlin Avatar
    Caitlin

    I also want to add to this that an ABA program should always be primarily focused on maximizing reinforcement across the lifespan: this means giving individuals the tools they need to be socially effective with communication, to advocate for themselves, to refuse what is not right for them, and to find safe ways to stim. ABA does NOT need to involve hours of “waiting it out” on a regular basis. Good planning and hefty supports in place BEFORE challenging behaviors occur and a heavy focus on functional communication can change everything.

    While there is some preliminary research to suggest that PTSD is a side effect of ABA treatment, we still need to know a lot more. We don’t know the intensity of the programs, the experience level of the staff, the level of parent involvement, the level of acceptability of treatment to those individuals and families, and a lot more before we can throw the baby out with the bath water.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Touched by what you read? Join the conversation!

  • Who doesn’t procrastinate?
    Who doesn’t procrastinate?

    These are the most common excuses people use when they procrastinate—delay doing what they need to do. How many of these have you personally used? According to the American Psychological Association, almost 80% of the people surveyed admit to lying to themselves about the reasons they put off doing things. So, who doesn’t procrastinate?    The…

    Read more >> about Who doesn’t procrastinate?

  • The Extraordinary You
    The Extraordinary You

    My autistic daughter has mentioned a Netflix show called “The Extraordinary Attorney Woo” a few times this year, and we finally got to watching the show today.  I didn’t want to like it at first because it seemed to fall into the stereotypical savant portrayal of autistic individuals in the media.    Hollywood’s infatuation with the…

    Read more >> about The Extraordinary You

  • Untitled post 43429

    My parents only cared about my grades. I think they may have been depressed while I was growing up. Definitely, no one practiced self-help techniques or knew about them in my family.

    Read more >> about this post